The Center for Philosophy of Science
Menu
Close
  • About the Center
    • Mission
    • History
    • Founder
    • Team
    • Publications
  • Programs
    • Overview
    • Visiting Fellows
    • Postdoc Fellowships
    • Senior Fellowships
    • Summer Archival Fellowship
    • Resident Fellowships
    • Associateships
    • Pittsburgh Summer Program
      • Past Summer Programs
    • International Partnerships
  • Fellows
    • Our Fellows
    • Resident Fellows
    • Associates
  • News
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Lunchtime Talks
    • Annual Lecture Series
      • Grünbaum Memorial Lecture
    • Conferences
      • Conferences
      • Past Conferences
      • Quad Fellows Conference
    • Center Debates & Online Events
  • Contact
  • Fellow Login
  • Fellow Login
  • About the Center
    • Mission
    • History
    • Founder
    • Team
    • Publications
  • Programs
    • Overview
    • Visiting Fellows
    • Postdoc Fellowships
    • Senior Fellowships
    • Summer Archival Fellowship
    • Resident Fellowships
    • Associateships
    • Pittsburgh Summer Program
      • Past Summer Programs
    • International Partnerships
  • Fellows
    • Our Fellows
    • Resident Fellows
    • Associates
  • News
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Lunchtime Talks
    • Annual Lecture Series
      • Grünbaum Memorial Lecture
    • Conferences
      • Conferences
      • Past Conferences
      • Quad Fellows Conference
    • Center Debates & Online Events
  • Contact
Events

Annual Lecture Series (in-person)

Lunchtime Talks (in-person)

Conferences (in-person)

Online-Only Events

Loading Events

« All Events

  • This event has passed.

ALS: C. Buckner

April 22 @ 3:30 pm - 5:30 pm EDT

  • « FFF: Alison Fernandes
  • LTT: A. Mohseni »

Cameron Buckner, Department of Philosophy, University of Houston

The new DoGMA of Empiricism: Deep Learning and Domain-General Faculties

Abstract:  Deep learning is a research area in computer science that has over the last ten years produced a series of transformative breakthroughs in artificial intelligence—creating systems that can recognize complex objects in natural photographs as well or better than humans, defeat human grandmasters in strategy games such as chess, Go, shoji, or Starcraft II, create “deepfake” images or bodies of text that are sometimes indistinguishable from those produced by humans, and predict how proteins will fold more accurately than human microbiologists who have devoted their lives to the task. In this talk, I argue that these achievements were inspired by and in turn vindicate a moderately empiricist approach to cognition.  However, this particular form of moderate empiricism has not been carefully articulated and defended in the computer science it has inspired.  This has allowed deep learning’s rationalist critics—such as Gary Marcus, Melanie Mitchell, and Judea Pearl, as well as (in the previous generation of neural network criticism) Steven Pinker, Jerry Fodor, and Zenon Pylyshyn—to define the rules of the debate on their own terms.  In this talk, I rebut this caricature by explicating the empiricism which undergirds most of these achievements.  In particular, I interpret them in terms of a Domain-General Modular Architecture (DoGMA) for cognition centered on active, general-purpose, innate faculties like perception, memory, imagination, attention, and empathy.  This empiricism echoes not the “radical” forms associated with behaviorism and logical positivism, but rather the more plausible forms defended by empiricist-leaning faculty psychologists such as Aristotle, Ibn Sina (Avicenna), John Locke, George Berkeley, David Hume, Adam Smith, and Sophie De Grouchy.  If the debate between rationalism and empiricism is to remain a useful framework for critique of deep learning—even for rationalists who might still think it ultimately wrong-headed—we must stop framing it as a sequel to the oft-recited fable in which the valiant young Chomsky vanquished the dark lord Skinner, and see it instead as a novel empirical exploration of the most ambitious ideas offered by historical faculty empiricists.

To attend this lecture via Zoom please visit: https://pitt.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_M_dQJZZaRS6oK371bkcE1A

Please Note: Non-Pitt individuals who want to attend our in-person talks must send an email in advance to Shoshi Burd-Baugh (shoshi.burdbaugh@pitt.edu) requesting Guest Building Access, or you will not be able to enter the Cathedral of Learning.

+ Add to Google Calendar+ Add to iCalendar+ Export .ics file

Details

Date:
April 22
Time:
3:30 pm - 5:30 pm EDT
Event Categories:
62nd Annual Lecture Series, 2021-22, Annual Lecture Series
Event Tags:
als

Venue

1008 Cathedral of Learning
4200 Fifth Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15260 United States
  • « FFF: Alison Fernandes
  • LTT: A. Mohseni »
Print Page

Categories

  • 60th Annual Lecture Series, 2019-20
  • 61st Annual Lecture Series, 2020-21
  • 62nd Annual Lecture Series, 2021-22
  • 63rd Annual Lecture Series
  • Annual Lecture Series
  • Center debates
  • Conferences 2019-20
  • Conferences 2020-21
  • Conferences 2021-22
  • Conferences 2022-23
  • Conferences, Workshops and Programs
  • Featured Former Fellow LTT
  • Lunch Time Talks 2022-2023
  • Lunchtime Talks
  • Lunchtime Talks 2020-21
  • Lunchtime Talks 2021-22
  • Online Events
  • PSP
  • Salmon Memorial Lecture
  • Calendar
  • Lunchtime Talks
  • Center Debates & Online Events
  • Annual Lecture Series
    • Grünbaum Memorial Lecture
  • Conferences
    • Current Conferences
    • Past Conferences
    • Quad Fellows Conference
The Center is a program of the University of Pittsburgh

Connect

  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2022 The Center for Philosophy of Science. All rights reserved.

Website by Imagebox